The Ultimate Clean Makeup Guide: Non-Toxic Swaps for Every Product in Your Routine

If you’ve ever squinted at the tiny ingredient list on your makeup label and wondered what even IS this stuff?, you’re not alone. In the world of beauty, we’re becoming more ingredient-savvy—and that’s a powerful thing. Clean makeup isn’t just a trend anymore—it’s a movement. A lifestyle. A love letter to your skin.

Let’s dive deep into a full-face clean makeup routine. We’ll break down exactly what toxic ingredients to avoid (and why), and I’ll introduce you to better, skin-loving alternatives for every product—from foundation to lipstick and everything in between.

So if you’re ready to glow without the guilt, let’s get into this clean makeup guide that’s optimized for your skin and your conscience.

Why Clean Makeup Matters

Clean makeup is all about safety, transparency, and sustainability. It means choosing products that are free from harmful chemicals, questionable preservatives, and irritating fillers—and packed with skin-loving, nourishing ingredients instead.

Common Toxic Ingredients to Avoid in Makeup

Here’s a cheat sheet of ingredients we don’t want anywhere near our face:

• Parabens (like methylparaben, propylparaben): Linked to hormone disruption.
• Phthalates (often hidden under “fragrance”): A known endocrine disruptor.
• Talc (may contain asbestos): A lung irritant and potential carcinogen.
• BHA/BHT: Preservatives that may cause skin irritation and hormone disruption.
• PEGs (Polyethylene Glycol): Petroleum-based and often contaminated with carcinogens.
• Synthetic Fragrance: Often a cocktail of dozens of undisclosed chemicals.
• Formaldehyde-releasing preservatives (like DMDM hydantoin): Carcinogenic and irritating.
• Heavy Metals (found in some pigments): Neurotoxic and linked to various health risks.
• Triclosan: Linked to thyroid issues and skin irritation.

Now that we know what to avoid, let’s talk about better, cleaner swaps. By choosing ingredients that are free of harsh chemicals, we have the ability to feed our skin with the nutrients it needs to thrive instead of drying it out and depleting it of necessary oils and healthy bacteria.

Clean Foundation: Flawless Skin, Naturally

What to Avoid:

• Silicones (like dimethicone): Can clog pores and trap bacteria.
• Parabens & PEGs: Linked to irritation and hormone disruption.
• Synthetic dyes and fragrances: Often unnecessary and irritating.

Clean Alternatives:

Look for foundations with:

• Aloe Vera: Calming and hydrating.
• Zinc Oxide/Titanium Dioxide (non-nano): For natural SPF.
• Plant-based pigments: Safer and gentler on skin.
• Jojoba oil or squalane: Balancing and breathable hydration.

My go-to clean foundations include Toups + Co. Organics Liquid Foundation for its lightweight feel yet flawless and buildable coverage that lasts, and the Oliveda Serum Skin Tint for its multi-tasking benefits that deliver hydration, antioxidant protection, and sheer, radiant coverage—all in one effortless step.

Pro tip: Choose buildable formulas (like these) that let your skin breathe while giving you customizable coverage. The right foundation can make all the difference in skin health and appearance.

Clean Powder

What to Avoid:

• Talc: A potential carcinogen and lung irritant.
• Silica (amorphous): Can be irritating in powder form.

Clean Alternatives:

Choose powders made with:

• Mica (ethically sourced): Gives a subtle glow.
• Arrowroot powder or rice powder: Absorb oil naturally.
• Kaolin clay: Detoxifies while setting makeup.

My favorite non-toxic powders are Toups + Co. Organics Mineral Makeup for its buildable and smooth coverage that won’t clog pores and even has a natural SPF, and Well People Super Powder for its versatility and ability to add brightness to the skin while blurring imperfections and fine lines.

Powder is not something I wear every day, but I love it alongside buildable foundations to give more coverage on the days I need it or want to have a more glam finished look. Depending on your skin type, a mineral powder foundation may be your only foundation need.

Clean Lipstick: Kiss Toxins Goodbye

What to Avoid:

• Lead and heavy metals: Yes, they’re still found in conventional lipsticks!
• Synthetic dyes (FD&C colors): Can be contaminated with heavy metals.
• Petroleum-based ingredients (like mineral oil): Not nourishing and not sustainable.

Clean Alternatives:

Go for lipsticks packed with:

• Beeswax or candelilla wax: For texture and moisture-lock.
• Shea butter, cocoa butter, avocado oil: Super nourishing for soft lips.
• Natural mineral pigments or fruit-based tints: Clean color with no nasties.

My top lip options include, you guessed it, Toups + Co. Organics. From their fabulous organic lip gloss to their traditional lipsticks, to even a tinted lip balm for just a hint of color, you can count on Toups lip products to give you the softest and most beautiful lip colors filled with nutrient-dense oils and concentrated pigments, whatever your shade is.

Toups’ lip collection has been a game changer for me, as traditional lip products would often give me both a headache and a stomachache from the artificial ingredients and smells. I gave up on lip color until I came across Toups + Co.

Another pro tip: Look for multi-use lip tints that double as cheek color—clean, simple, and perfect for a no-makeup makeup vibe. Or try a shiny lip balm like Oliveda’s Olive Tree Therapy Lip Balm to rejuvenate, tone, and define dry and cracked lips, leaving you with the most supple and glossy natural lips.

Clean Mascara: Flutter Without the Flakes

What to Avoid:

• Carbon black: A potential carcinogen.
• Formaldehyde-releasing preservatives: Big no for your eye area.
• Synthetic fibers: Can irritate or scratch your eyes.

Clean Alternatives:

Reach for mascaras made with:

• Natural waxes (beeswax, carnauba): For buildable volume.
• Plant-based pigments (like black tea or charcoal): Safe, deep color.
• Vitamin E and castor oil: For lash conditioning and growth support.

The best mascara on the market by far is from Ilia Beauty. Whether you prefer a thick applicator brush like Ilia’s Fullest Volume Mascara to build and define your lashes or a precise comb-type brush like Ilia’s Limitless Lash Mascara, both formulas will leave your lashes lengthened, defined and all without smudging.

Ilia’s Mascara formulas have won multiple awards for best mascara (clean or not) and receive rave reviews everywhere you look.

Pro Tip: Curl lashes first, then apply from root to tip using a wiggle motion for max length. I use both Ilia formulas, applying first the Limitless Mascara to comb out lashes and then finishing with Fullest Volume for length and definition. You will not be disappointed by either formula!

Clean Eyeshadow: Pop Your Eyes Without Irritation

What to Avoid:

• Talc
• Heavy metals (especially in bright or metallic pigments)
• Synthetic dyes (Red 40, Blue 1, etc.)

Clean Alternatives:

Clean eyeshadows should feature:

• Mineral-based pigments: Long-lasting color without toxins.
• Arrowroot powder or rice starch: Helps with smooth application.
• Botanical extracts: Like chamomile or calendula to soothe sensitive lids.

The best non-toxic eyeshadows on the market include Toups + Co. Organics Natural Eyeshadow and Ilia’s The Necessary Eyeshadow Palette. Both options are talc-free and highly pigmented to define your eyes and can take you from natural daytime looks to full evening glam. Toups + Co. offers individual colors to customize your own palette or multiple three-color shadow palettes that complement each other. Ilia offers two palette options with cool tones or warm tones, whichever your preference.

From shimmers to mattes, clean eyeshadow has come a long way—and these days, the pigment payoff is just as good, dare I say, even way better than the toxic stuff.

Clean Eyeliner: Define Safely

What to Avoid:

• Carbon black
• Formaldehyde preservatives
• PEG compounds
• Petroleum-based binders

Clean Alternatives:

Best clean eyeliners include:

• Iron oxides for safe pigmentation.
• Aloe vera and shea butter for smooth application.
• Plant-based waxes for staying power.

My favorite eyeliners are Toups + Co. Organics Natural Eyeliner for its silky smooth application and dense pigment that is gentle on my sensitive eyes, and Ilia for its variety of eyeliners, from gel to liquid to pencil that last.

Eyeliner is the earrings of your makeup outfit. It adds just a little extra pop and detail that completes a look. Want a smudgy, smoky eye? Opt for a soft pencil liner. Prefer crisp lines? Try a water-based clean liquid liner with a fine felt tip to complete your look.

Clean Blush: Flush of Color, Minus the Chemicals

What to Avoid:

• Synthetic dyes
• Fragrance
• Talc

Clean Alternatives:

Clean blushes use:

• Natural clays: For blendability.
• Botanical oils: Like jojoba or rosehip for hydration.
• Mica (ethically sourced): For a glowy finish.

I have officially become a cream blush girl. I love the soft glow it gives my skin and doubles as a lip color. I am all about simplifying beauty and love that I can keep less in my makeup drawer with multi-use products. My favorite cream blush is Toups + Co. Organics Cream Cheek Tint for its long-lasting color that blends seamlessly. Toups also offers a great powder blush that gives a soft finish.

Another go-to blush would be Ilia’s. Ilia offers multiple blush options depending on your preference, from their Multi-Stick Blush to their Color Haze Multi-Use Matte Pigment. Both are beautiful, clean options for rosy cheeks and lips. Whether you’re into cream blush or powder, there’s a clean version for every finish and skin type.

Bronzer + Highlighter: A Natural Glow

What to Avoid:

• Talc
• Synthetic Fragrance (Parfum)
• Bismuth Oxychloride
• Parabens (methylparaben, propylparaben, etc.)
• Petroleum-derived ingredients (mineral oil, paraffin, petrolatum)
• Nanoparticles

Clean Alternatives:

• Ethically sourced Mica
• Rice Powder or Cornstarch
• Essential Oils (used sparingly) or Fragrance-Free formulas
• Silica or Zinc Oxide
• Vitamin E (Tocopherol) or Sodium Benzoate
• Jojoba Oil, Squalane, Shea Butter, Coconut Alkanes
• Non-Nano Zinc Oxide
• Iron Oxides, Fruit Pigments, Beetroot Extract

Clean bronzer adds warmth, depth, and a soft sun-kissed glow—without any of the junk. Made with nourishing, non-toxic pigments and silky, blendable minerals, it melts into your skin like a second layer. My favorite bronzer is Toups + Co. Bronzer for its soft shimmer and buildable pigment. Whether you’re contouring or just chasing that “just got back from the beach” vibe, this bronzer brings the glow and the goodness.

I love the Toups + Co. Highlighter. This luminizer delivers a dewy, lit-from-within sheen thanks to skin-loving botanicals and zero sparkle fallout. Packed with natural pearlescence and ingredients that support your skin barrier. Swipe it on your cheekbones, eyelids, or cupid’s bow for that subtle magic moment in every light.

Bonus: Clean Makeup Brushes & Tools

Your makeup is only as clean as your tools. Even the best clean makeup won’t perform if you’re using brushes that shed plastic or house bacteria. Opt for silicone blenders or brushes with natural bristles.

Wash tools weekly using a non-toxic brush cleanser—or even gentle Castile soap and warm water. Lay flat to dry to make sure no bacteria or mold creeps in.

Featured Products

Toups + Co. Organics

Enjoy 10% Off!

Shop Here

Olive Tree People

Skincare + Makeup

Shop Here

Ilia Beauty

Makeup

Shop Here

Quick Tips to Transition to Clean Makeup

1. Start with the basics: Swap your foundation and mascara first—these sit closest to your skin and eyes.
2. Patch test new products: Even clean ingredients can cause reactions in rare cases.
3. Read the full ingredient list: Don’t trust just the marketing on the label.
4. Less is more: Clean makeup is often more pigmented and concentrated, so a little goes a long way.
5. Check certifications: Look for EWG Verified, Leaping Bunny, and MADE SAFE seals when possible.

Clean Skin = Better Makeup

Let’s not forget: Clean makeup looks best on clean, nourished skin. Support your routine with non-toxic skincare that includes:

• Gentle cleansers
• Balancing toners
• Moisturizers with hyaluronic acid, squalane, and aloe vera
• Mineral SPF (non-nano zinc oxide)

Your clean makeup will sit better, blend easier, and last longer when your skin is prepped and happy. Promise. Don’t forget to drink ample water with electolytes, bone broth, and add in some collagen for extra glowing skin from the inside out.

My trusted and tested clean skincare brands are Oliveda for its powerhouse Hydroxytyrosol and its luxurious, olive-based skincare that blends potent natural actives with scientific innovation to hydrate, renew, and illuminate your skin, and Toups + Co. Organics for its nutrient-dense and skin-loving tallow base, handcrafted in coastal Alabama.

Both companies pride themselves on natural ingredients and waterless beauty, which nourish the skin without the unnecessary preservatives that come with the addition of water. Less water means more powerful ingredients packed into your bottle for longer-lasting skincare that delivers.

Clean Beauty, Empowered Choices

You don’t have to compromise on performance or aesthetics to go clean. Today’s clean makeup is chic, luxurious, and—best of all—safe. Whether you’re making one swap at a time or overhauling your whole routine, you’re doing something beautiful for yourself.

Every swipe, every blend, every bold lip or fluttery lash is a small act of self-care. Our bodies were made with purpose and for a purpose, and even small choices like the makeup we use every day have a lasting impact on not just our bodies, but our minds, and spirits too.

Drop your favorite clean makeup products in the comments—I love to hear your personal testimonials!

Hey, Sweet Friend!

Welcome! I’m Ashley, a lover of beauty in all its facets. I am a hairstylist, writer, & girl mom passionate about helping women flourish by seeking beauty beyond the surface. I love to encourage women to create clean & healthy beauty habits & homes grounded in faith and live by my motto…clean, pretty, + simple. I would love for you to join me in your healthy beauty journey!

Learn More